Menu  
Close  
  • Who we are
  • Our work
  • News & Analysis
  • Events
  • Library
Accessibility options
Search the site

The cost of hate speech: Policy brief for Punjab

Category: Policy Brief By: Aila Gill & Cecil Shane Chaudhry & Kashif Aslam & Sharoon Sharif & Zeeba T. Hashmi

This policy brief provides a clear overview of hate speech towards religious and
sectarian minorities in Pakistan, and its detrimental effects, an analysis of the current
legislation in place and a series of recommendations to fill the lacunas in state
policy towards hate speech and support the implementation of existing policies
designed to prevent it.

Pakistan is a religiously diverse country. Since its inception in 1947, it has been facing issues of intolerance and hate speech. Despite all legal provisions against hate speech, it has been allowed to flourish with impunity in practice. Hate speech in textbooks, print and electronic media including in sermons delivered through clerics have torn the social fabric of our society.

Pakistan ratified the International Convent on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) in 2009. Laws relating to hate speech exist in Section 505 (2) of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) that makes creating or promoting “feelings of enmity, hatred or ill-will between different religious, racial, language or regional groups or castes or communities” punishable. These legal provisions cover firmly the offenses identified as hate speech in the article 19 and 20 of ICCPR. Thus, the existing legal framework of Pakistan provides ample space to government to take action against hate mongers.

After the terrorists’ attack in 2014, at the Army Public school in Peshawar, a National Action Plan (NAP) was formed to counter terrorism in the country. Among 20 points within this NAP, the fifth one focused on “Strict action against the literature, newspapers and magazines promoting hatred, extremism, sectarianism and intolerance”.

Unfortunately, despite all these legal provisions against hate speech, little has been done in practice. On December 27, 2014 an Ahmadi, Luqman Ahmad, was shot dead in district Gujranwala after a Muslim leader denounced Ahmadis on a popular television show. On December 30, 2014 the television apologized for its editorial negligence. The assassination of the former Governor of Punjab, Salman Taseer, reminds us of a campaign of hate speech that was carried out against him and the announcement of a bounty to incite his murder. Members of religious minorities are facing the issue of hate speech constantly.

Terrorism has deep roots in hate crimes. In the context of Pakistan, it is urgently needed to implement the existing laws regarding hate speech.

Download this Policy Brief

See also…

Online hatred pushing minorities to the periphery: An analysis of Pakistani social media feeds (publication)

I Don’t Forward Hate (project)

Related content

Analysis
3 years of CREID: reflection and planning in Istanbul

There was probably no better place than Istanbul to hold CREID’s first face-to-face event, which took place early February, after two years of online gatherings.…

VIEW THIS RESOURCE
Analysis From Afghanistan to Pakistan, the never-ending ordeals of Shi’a Hazaras

Researchers Maryam Kanwer and Jaffer Mirza speak to Shia Hazara Afghan refugees who are living in fear and hiding in Pakistan. ‘There were so many…

VIEW THIS RESOURCE
Podcast
Countering online hate speech: creating a counter narrative through good journalism and by working with young people

In this final episode in our series on identifying and countering hate speech, Emily Buchanan speaks to Salam Omer, Editor-in-Chief at KirkukNow in Iraq, Abdul…

VIEW THIS RESOURCE
Back to top
  • Accessibility
  • Terms of use
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy & cookies
  • Contact

[email protected]

CREID team
Institute of Development Studies
Library Road
University of Sussex
Falmer BN1 8RE
East Sussex, United Kingdom

Sign up to our newsletter

Our mailing list is managed by
Institute of Development Studies

© 2022 CREID. Made by Surface Impression.



These options can change the way this website looks, which may help you to use it more easily.

Accessibility options


  •   Text options

Text options

Standard text

Standard text size

Large text

Large text size

Extra large text

Extra large text size